Could the Salem Witch Trails Happen Again?
Hocus Pocus, arguably one of the coolest Halloween movies of all time, is (very loosely) based on the history of one event: The Salem Witch trails. So, I propose a question: could the horrors of 1692 repeat themselves, or are we free to make blockbuster hits that use the concepts without worrying about it happening again?
In 1692, over 20 people were killed over accusations of witchcraft. One man was even pressed to death, but what were the causes of this witchcraft hysteria? One of the first causes is called "Mob psychology," also known as group think. If you read Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events, you might be aware that in the story the protagonists (Violet, Klaus and likely not Sunny Baudelaire) shout opinions into an angry mob so that they can escape a bad situation. However, group think can also work in the opposite way and make people more likely to do terrible things. You can think of this like a flock of sheep following a shepherd. In the case of the Salem Witch trails the sheep were hanging other sheep and the shepherds were children (or you could say lambs).
Mob psychology isn’t the only phenomena that can be used to help explain the mass hysteria. In sociology there is a popular theory called ‘in groups and out groups’. It is also known as Us vs. Them mentally. Now as you hopefully are well aware humans are naturally social creatures, so if we go without people for too long we can feel lonely and get upset. That's the idea of Us vs. Them mentally. You can think of it as having a friend group. You want to stay in this group and are willing to do things to keep it that way (Even if it’s peer pressure, I’ll circle back to that). Those in your group are seen as safe and desirable. Out groups, on the other hand, are seen as threats or even enemies (Fabiana, 2024). This kind of mentally historically had kept us alive back in ancient and prehistoric times. But, in the case of the Salem Witch Trials it ed to people accusing local town outcasts of witchcraft.
The next topic I want to briefly talk about is peer pressure. I could explain the obvious aspects about how it was definitely not a coincidence that rivals of the Putnam family were accused moreregularly, or anyone who dared to ask the question of “Should we really give little kids this much power in our town?” I want to talk about the number of false confessions that added flames to the fire. 1/3 of confessions were false. Over 150 accused and 1/3 of them lied and said that they were in fact witches (and accused others) knowing that they would die. The sheer amount of confessions added so much more trust in the accusers and made the situation worse than it already was (McAree, 2024).
So, am I saying that all we need to make the Salem Witch Trails happen again is some well placed and well known psychological tactics, and people will go insane accusing people of witchcraft again? No, that's not what I’m saying, other than Salem being a very small isolated town (which is why the situation ended up blowing up so fast), there is also a second cause to explain the ‘evidence’ that people believed they were seeing, Ergot fungus (Teeny, 2025). Ergot fungus is like a psychedelic parasite. It contains toxins that infested different grains that were used to bake bread. The people of Salem were eating this bread, and it’s known to cause hallucinations and convulsions. You got a paranoid small isolated town that is already a victim of mind games being unintentionally (or perhaps internally) thrown at them eating bread that causes hallucinations.
You might be wondering what this fungus has to do with today? Well, there are many other plants that people consume (in a variety of ways) that also can cause hallucinations. An article written for Encyclopedia Britannica lists nine of them (Petruzzello,2025). The one I want to focus on is cannabis, commonly known as marijuana. Cannabis has been known to increase the likelihood of mental illnesses like schizophrenia. In addition, Marijuana is becoming legalized in more states. In the state of Massachusetts marijuana is legal with some restrictions (Commonwealth of Massachusetts,2026). People today are more aware of the dangers with Ergot fungus; however, people bake cannabis into food and consume it.
So to summarise everything, the Salem Witch Trails happened because of psychological events in a small isolated area, and because of a mind altering fungus. All of these events have the real possibility of being replicated, and that’s why it’s so important to be aware. During the witch trails, people didn’t think this was mass hysteria. So while it may never happen again on such an extreme scale (hopefully), the ingredients to cause this weren't magical at all. Therefore, it is invaluable to be able to read the signs, so we can avoid a tragedy.
Works Cited
Commonwealth of Massachusetts.. “Massachusetts Law about Recreational Marijuana.” Mass.Gov, 2026, https://www.mass.gov/info-details/massachusetts-law-about-recreational-marijuana.
Fabiana Franco Ph.D. “The Psychological Processes That Form Our Representations of ‘Us’ and ‘Them..’” Psychology Today, 15 Oct. 2024, https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/trauma-resilience-and-recovery/202410/in-group-and-out-group-dynamics-a-psychological.
McAree, Caylie. “Confessions in the Salem Witch Trials.” Scholars Archive, 2024, https://scholarsarchive.library.albany.edu/all_honors/20.
Petruzzello, and Melissa. “9 Mind-Altering Plants | Opium, Peyote, Marijuana, Ayahuasca, Betel, Coca, Salvia, Tobacco, and Facts.” Encyclopedia Britannica, 19 Aug. 2026, www.britannica.com/list/9-mind-altering-plants.
Teeny, Jake. “Salem Psychology.” Everyday Psych, 7 Feb. 2025,
4
Comments